Sodom on the Trinity (Part 1): A Cold Day in Hell

It was, in a literal sense, larger than the “half acre” of its name. It was, in a figurative sense, smaller than the legends that survive it more than a century later. Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid holed up in it. So did Sam Bass and his gang. Mary Porter played mother hen to the “soiled doves” of its “gilded palaces of sin.” City Marshal Jim Courtright was ordered to clean it up. J. Frank Norris was determined to shut it down.

And a lot of people lost their money, their innocence, and even their lives in it.

hell's half acre label2It was Hell’s Half Acre, and for more than thirty years it was a sin-and-gin model of supply and demand, a two-fisted, pistol-packin’, card-sharpin’, hard-drinkin’, easy-lovin’ veritable mall of vice that reduced “greenhorns” to empty-pocketed drunks and reduced reformers to tears.

In the nineteenth century many towns had a vice district, and several were called “Hell’s Half Acre,” including those in San Antonio, Augusta, Cincinnati, Nashville, Brenham, Tascosa, and Kansas City. But none was wilder or woolier than Cowtown’s Acre.

The Acre—and its location—was a logical response to the cattle drives on the Chisholm Trail during the 1870s. All that beef on the hoof and all that testosterone on the saddle entered Fort Worth from the south bound for the railhead in Abilene, Kansas. The trail skirted Fort Worth on the east along a corridor from today’s Commerce Street to Grove Street. Vice was right there on Cowtown’s back porch to greet the boys with a deck of cards, a bottle of whiskey, and a perfumed wink. The Acre (covering about fifty acres) was bounded roughly by 10th Street south to Lancaster and Throckmorton Street east to Jones Street. (St. Patrick’s Cathedral was on the western edge, the brewery of Texas Brewing Company on its eastern edge.) The Convention Center and Water Gardens now cover most of the Acre. Within the fifty-acre Half Acre were saloons, dance halls, gambling houses, “honk-a-tonks,” opium dens, cockfight pits, and brothels. And within those establishments often was violence: gunfights, knife fights, fistfights, muggings, and suicides among gamblers, cowboys, prostitutes, tinhorns, and greenhorns. Not to mention assorted ways to separate a man from his money.

This clip from the Fort Worth Daily Democrat in 1883 describes the ambience of the Acre.

In 1887 the Daily Gazette lamented: “It’s a cold day when the Half Acre doesn’t pan out a cutting or shooting scrape among its male denizens, and a morphine experiment by some of its frisky females.”

Of course, the Acre (located in the Third Ward) also was the home and workplace of law-abiding people who lived in its tenements and boardinghouses and worked in its laundries, groceries, and livery stables. But they seldom made the headlines except as victims. The headlines above from Fort Worth newspapers are from the late nineteenth century.

acre soiled dove

The life of prostitutes in the Acre was, to borrow from Thomas Hobbes, “nasty, brutish, and short.” Their rates of suicide and drug abuse were high.

A Hell’s Half Acre Glossary (Part 1)

bagnio: brothel
disorderly house: brothel
soiled dove: prostitute
woman of the town: prostitute

The Acre had dozens of saloons, but the White Elephant was not one of them. The White Elephant was located uptown just three blocks from the courthouse. However, the Acre did have the Black Elephant Saloon. It catered to African-American “sports,” although proprietor West Mayweather said he welcomed any color, especially green.

A Hell’s Half Acre Glossary (Part 2)

demimonde: prostitute
vag: vagrant; vagrancy was sometimes a charge for prostitution
sport: gambler
Third Ward: the city political district containing Hell’s Half Acre, created in 1877

(The Third Ward was sometimes called the “bloody Third.”)
In late 1900 Butch Cassidy, the Sundance Kid, and the rest of the Wild Bunch rode into town and holed up for a few weeks in Maddox Flats on Main Street in the Acre. They had just robbed a bank in Winnemucca, Nevada of $32,000 ($936,000 today).

While staying at Maddox Flats, located where the convention center is today, the boys strolled up the street to the studio of photographer John Swartz at 705 Main Street to pose for a photo.

Sitting, left to right: Harry Longabaugh (Sundance Kid), Ben Kilpatrick, Robert Leroy Parker (Butch Cassidy).
Standing, left to right: Will Carver, Harvey Logan (Kid Curry).

According to Fort Worth historian Dr. Richard F. Selcer in Hell’s Half Acre, John Swartz later posted a copy of the photo in the front window of his studio. A private detective—either for Wells Fargo or the Pinkerton agency—saw the photo and recognized one or more of the gang members. The Pinkerton detective agency used the photo as the basis of a wanted poster. Fort Worth Chief of Police William M. Rea also distributed the photo to lawmen in other cities. (Photo from Wikipedia.)

Fifteen thousand posters were plastered across the country. Private detectives and lawmen descended on Fort Worth as the manhunt gained a focus. Gang member Harvey Logan, Selcer writes, later recalled, “One day one of us saw a Pinkerton detective on the street, and in thirty minutes the [Maddox] apartment was empty.” The gang split up. At least three members, Selcer writes, holed up in San Antonio. Butch and Sundance, accompanied by Etta Place, sailed to South America and into western legend. (Photo from Tarrant County College NE, Heritage Room.)

Sodom on the Trinity (Part 2): Gilded Palaces of Sin

Posts About Crime Indexed by Decade

This entry was posted in Crime, Downtown, Downtown, All Around, Life in the Past Lane. Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Sodom on the Trinity (Part 1): A Cold Day in Hell

  1. Christopher Stinnett says:

    Looking at the map, St.Patrick’s Cathedral (then just Saint Patrick’s Church) sat facing into the northwest corner of the acre.

  2. John Olthoff says:

    Everyone talks about Dodge City, yet Fort Worth (at least in this area)was probably wilder

  3. mark perkins says:

    I grew up in White Settlement and would like to know if there are any aerial photos of that area before the Airforce factory was built or before lake worth was impounded. Also any stories of Indian activity in that area
    Thanks M

    • hometown says:

      Mark: Because the lake was impounded in 1914, aerials before that date are less likely than aerials before the bomber plant and airfield. The closest I can come is this: Search Google images for “Lake Worth seaplanes.” There is a 1940 aerial of the lake with seaplanes on it. But I do not know what, if any, part of the bomber plant/airfield site is shown.
      There is a White Settlement Historical Museum website that has an article on early history and lists some books:

      http://www.wsmuseum.com/bookprices.html
      http://www.wsmuseum.com/wshist.html

  4. Jane Finley Eggenberger says:

    Mike Thank you so very much for the Hells Half Acre articles. I loved it. I had no idea that there was a Black Elephant Sallon. It certainly was a wild time wasn’t it. There is a bust statue in downtown by the train station and where the old Frank Kent Dealership was. My mom said the statue is dedicated to a man who rescued alot of people at a fire in that area. Do you know anything about it?

Leave a Reply to Christopher Stinnett Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *