Boyce House (Part 1): “Santa Claus, Why Did You Rob That Bank?”

The time: ninety-five years ago.
The place: ninety-one miles southwest of Fort Worth.
It was December 23, 1927, and in the small town of Cisco in rural Eastland County, Santa Claus was about to bring Boyce House a most unexpected Christmas present: fame.

Boyce House was editor of the newspaper in the town of Eastland, the county seat eight miles from Cisco. His coverage of an eccentric crime in late 1927 and of an equally eccentric (but more benign) news event in early 1928 would propel House from Eastland to Fort Worth, where he would live, die, and be buried. His coverage would also propel him from writing about the west Texas oil fields to writing books and a syndicated column, hosting his own radio program, and answering the call of Hollywood and politics.

But first let’s go back to December 23, 1927 and the town of Cisco, where at the First National Bank things were about to go horribly wrong for Santa and his three elves.

Marshall Ratliff, age twenty-four, was a local ex-con.

In 1926 Ratliff and his brother Lee had held up the bank in Valera (Coleman County). Cisco Police Chief G. E. “Bit” Bedford had been among the lawmen responsible for Marshall Ratliff being captured, convicted, and sent to prison. Ratliff had been paroled but had not learned his lesson. He wanted a do-over. So, on December 23, 1927 Ratliff, wearing a Santa Claus costume made for him by his former landlady, entered the First National Bank of Cisco with fellow ex-cons Henry Helms and Robert Hill. All three had done time at Huntsville state prison. Along for the sleigh ride was Louis Davis, a relative of Helms. Davis had never been in trouble with the law. He just needed some Christmas money.

As Santa and his elves entered the bank, tagging along with him were local children who had been understandably thrilled to see St. Nick himself walking down the sidewalk of their little town just two days before Christmas. But as Ratliff entered the bank, he did not respond with a jolly “Ho ho ho!” to the greetings of “Hello, Santa!” from people in the bank lobby. Instead, elf no. 1, Robert Hill, pointed a pistol at a cashier and shouted, “Hands up!” Elves nos. 2 and 3, Helms and Davis, also waved pistols.

Then, in a perversity that could scar a child forever, even Santa whipped out a rod.

Ratliff took money from the tellers, a safe, and the vault.

Undetected by the four robbers, bank customer Mrs. B. P. Blassengame was able to sneak out of the lobby and alert Police Chief Bedford.

According to Boyce House, Bedford was “a giant of a man and a veteran peace officer.” Bedford grabbed a riot gun and headed for the alley beside the bank. He told officers R. T. Redies and George Carmichael to cover the back door of the bank.

After the robbery came a gunfight worthy of the wild West. The four robbers and the three policemen began shooting. They were soon joined by civilian residents of Cisco. Some brought their own guns to the fight; others rushed to hardware stores to get guns. At that time the Texas Bankers Association offered a $5,000 reward to anyone shooting a bank robber. No doubt the prospect of a reward was an added incentive to some of the armed residents.

As the gunfight continued, the robbers shot their way to their getaway car in the alley. They took with them two hostages from the bank to serve as human shields: Laverne Comer, age twelve, and Emma May Robertson, age ten.

The robbers fled town with the two girls. The shooting stopped. Chief Bedford and officer Carmichael were fatally wounded. Six other citizens of Cisco were wounded. Robbers Ratliff and Davis also were wounded. The bank building was riddled with an estimated two hundred bullet holes.

house 12-24-27 pi

house 12-24-27 bedford photo jump

Officer Redies and other residents of Cisco formed an impromptu posse and pursued Santa and his elves. The largest manhunt in Texas to that date was under way for the desperado Santa Claus.

As the robbers left town, they realized that they had forgotten to fill their car’s gas tank before the robbery. With the Redies posse in pursuit, the robbers stopped a car driven by fourteen-year-old Woodrow Wilson Harris. Young Woodrow surrendered his car. The robbers piled into the new car with the bank money and hostages while being fired upon by Redies et al. The robbers started to make their escape.

But wait! Where were the keys to the commandeered car? They sure weren’t in the car’s ignition switch. That’s because young Woodrow had slyly pocketed the keys as he surrendered the car. Panicking, Ratliff, Helms, and Hill climbed back into their original getaway car with the two hostages, leaving injured Louis Davis in the keyless car. The Cisco posse continued to shoot at the robbers.

Ratliff, Helms, and Hill sped away with the two hostages. The robbers did not realize until later that they had left the bank money behind with Davis in the keyless car.

Redies et al. arrested Davis and recovered the bank money—$12,400 ($163,000 today). Davis, who had no previous criminal record, soon died in the Tarrant County jail.

house 12-25-27 bandit dies pi

The manhunt continued. Pursued by the Cisco posse, the three surviving robbers threw roofing nails out their car window to puncture the tires of their pursuers. The robbers then veered into a pasture and got the car entangled in a thicket of scrub oak, cactus, and mesquite. The robbers abandoned the car and the two hostages and fled on foot.

Eastland County Sheriff John Hart and his deputies then joined the manhunt. Boyce House and other journalists followed in their own cars. House wrote that “officers and citizens poured in from all that section of the state . . . Many members of the posse were on horseback or on foot as they beat their way through clumps of trees, searched high grass in the bottoms of ravines, and peered around boulders in canyons.”

The three robbers stole another car the next morning—Christmas Eve.

During a church service that night in Eastland, as a very different Saint Nicholas appeared before a group of children, one boy called out: “Santa Claus, why did you rob that bank?”

The manhunt continued. The robbers wrecked their latest getaway car and commandeered a car carrying a father and son. The robbers fled in the new car with the son as hostage. The father fired his shotgun at the fleeing car, wounding his son.

The next day the three robbers abandoned their latest car and latest hostage and stole yet another car. The next morning the three robbers were ambushed in Young County by Sheriff Jim Foster and deputies.

Another gunfight ensued.

Marshall Ratliff went down, wounded. When captured he reportedly was a “walking arsenal,” carrying six pistols and bearing an equal number of gunshot wounds. Santa Claus had been caught, but elves nos. 2 and 3 escaped on foot. Helms and Hill disappeared into the woods at the Brazos River.

house 12-29-27 pi

santa elves caught 12-31-27 dmnHelms and Hill, weak from injuries and lack of food, were caught in Graham one week after the Santa Claus Bank Robbery. Clip is from the December 31, 1927 Dallas Morning News.

santa helms to die 7-6-29 dmnHelms was executed by electric chair. Hill was sentenced to ninety-nine years in prison.  He escaped from prison three times. On his third escape he left behind a note reading, “If you want me you’ll have to come to Paris, France.” He made it as far as Houston before he was captured. Sacre bleu! Clip is from the July 6, 1929 Dallas Morning News.

santa ratliff escapes 11-19-29 dmnAnd Santa Claus? Marshall Ratliff, too, was sentenced to death. He was sent to Huntsville state prison, but his mother arranged to have him taken back to Eastland for a sanity hearing. While in the Eastland County jail awaiting that hearing, Ratliff managed to get a pistol from an office desk and fatally wounded a jailer while attempting to escape. Ratliff was subdued and returned to his county jail cell. Clip is from the November 19, 1929 Dallas Morning News.

santa ratliff body 11-21-29 dmnBut within hours an angry mob of almost two thousand people gathered outside the jail, demanding that Ratliff be turned over to them. The jailer refused but was overpowered. Clip is from the November 21, 1929 Dallas Morning News.

The mob dragged Ratliff to a vacant lot behind the Majestic Theater and lynched the ersatz Santa. The title of the play being presented at the theater at the time? The Noose.

house 11-21-29 ratliff dead

No one was ever tried for the lynching.

ratliff-prisonMarshall Ratliff’s prisoner profile at Huntsville state prison: Methodist, size 7 shoe, ninth-grade education, serving ninety-nine years for murder . . . “lynched 11-19-1929.”

santa ratliff buried 11-24-29 dmnMarshall Ratliff is buried in Fort Worth’s Mount Olivet Cemetery in an unmarked grave. Clip is from the November 24, 1929 Dallas Morning News.

The bank building still stands on Cisco’s Conrad Hilton Boulevard.

Whew. What a story. As a journalist, Boyce House was in the right place at the right time that Christmas of 1927. He broke the story of the Santa Claus Bank Robbery, calling it “the most spectacular crime in the history of the Southwest . . . surpassing any in which Billy the Kid or the James boys had ever figured.”


With Boyce House’s newspaper taking the lead, the eccentric crime, its violence, and, yes, its ineptness received national attention. In 1930 House retold the tale for Startling Detective Adventures magazine (above). The Santa Claus Bank Robbery was the first of two events that would propel the writing career of Boyce House. Two months after the robbery, Eastland County would tear down its old courthouse:

Boyce House (Part 2): “The Frog Was Alive!”

Posts About Crime Indexed by Decade

This entry was posted in Crime, Life in the Past Lane. Bookmark the permalink.

16 Responses to Boyce House (Part 1): “Santa Claus, Why Did You Rob That Bank?”

  1. C. Donati says:

    My neighbor tells me that the survivor, Mr. Hill once lived in the house I now own south of Cross Plains. Does anyone know what Mr. Hill changed his name to after he turned his life around?

  2. Pingback: Santa Claus Robbery – CIA

  3. Tommy Britain says:

    Was told by my uncle who was on main St as they passed the house you could hear the shots.then Grandma told us to get in here right thay passed bye with the police right behind them.

  4. Tommy Britain says:

    Was told by my uncle who was on main St as they passed the house you could hear the shots.then Grandma told us to get in here right thay passed bye with the police right behind them

  5. Penny Jordan says:

    Jonas has been biking it to you well nigh on thirty years yet no blog presence for the llama? How, ahem, odious.

  6. Gummi Bear says:

    I love this story. It’s always the first botched crime story that comes to mind when the subject comes up.

    I’ve spent significant parts of my life in Eastland county, and have visited many of the sites and tried to retrace some of the routes they used.

    The buildings are still standing in Cisco, and you can go visit them as well.

    I have been to several movies (the most recent being last month) in the Majestic theater which the lynching occurred behind. It is still open, and they show movies on Friday and Saturday nights.

    There’s a really good book about the robbery by A.C. Greene, and it reads like a fiction book. The actions of the robbers were so outlandish that it is really entertaining.

    • hometown says:

      When you read Greene’s book you wonder why it took so long for someone to see a book in that robbery.

  7. Jack Therwhanger says:

    I served as a state trooper stationed at Eastland from 9-15-62 until I was promoted to sergeant and transferred to the panhandle district 3-1-69.

    I was very interested in the robbery. Sheriff John Hart, brother of my former captain in my previous assignment passed away after serving for years as County Judge, just a few days befor e I arrived. Ranger Captain Tom Hickman had retired and then appointed by the governor to the Public Safety Commission. Ranger Sergeant Manuel T. Gonzales had served as a ranger captain, with a colorful career, then retired for a career in Hollywood.

    I was very interested in the Santa Claus escapade. The old timers there willingly spoke about the robbery and manhunt, but when the lynching came up, no one knew anything. Understandable, most anyone living in Eastland county in 1927 (close to sixty or older) could be suspect in the lynching and the statute of limitations is still running on murder. My interest was more historical, as I had heard of the crime when I was a child, but the locals, even friends, tended to treat me as a cold case investigator in this matter. To my recollection, the grand jury also came up against a wall of silence. What amazed me was that some two thousand were in the lynch mob, yet no one talked. Today there would be videos.

    • hometown says:

      It was quite a story. Perhaps no detail of the story shows how much the world has changed more than your observation that no one blabbed about the lynching. Today video of the lynching would be playing nonstop on YouTube and CNN, recorded on smartphones by participants.

  8. Mike, I was reading your latest post on the South Side Fire and saw the “Santa Clause Robbery” on your favorites. I thought you might like to know about the “Clarkson Connection” to this. One of the early houses my grandfather designed in Ryan Place was in 1912 for Mr. Alex Spears, business man and realtor. Spears lived in the house for a short time and sold it to William H. Francis, attorney with the Lone Star Gas Co. Francis lived in the house until 1918, when he sold it to Brandon Stone. Stone’s father helped write the Texas Constitution. The home remained in the Stone family until the 1960’s. No further info has been found on Alex Spears in Fort Worth after selling the home to Francis. In 1916, the Texas Banks Record, Volume 6, Page 43, states that a new bank was expected to open in Cisco and Alex Spears is named as the Cashier. My grandfather lists a house designed (or re-modeled) for Alex Spears in Cisco. An additional project is also tied to Spears, which was the remodeling of the First National Bank of Cisco, circa 1928. Spears would become the president of the bank and would keep the bank operating efficiently during the Great Depression when many banks, especially in smaller communities, would close. He was working at the bank as the Cashier on Dec 23, 1927 when the Santa Clause Robbery occurred and was wounded in the jaw during the shooting that occurred in the commission of the robbery. Recent information has convinced me that Alex Spears hired my grandfather to remodel the bank building after the Santa Clause Robbery on Dec 23, 1927. The bank was apparently severely shot up during the robbery as many of the town citizens took part in the shootout that occurred during the robbery. Further information is required before this is an absolute fact but the time frame of the remodeling job lines up with the year following the robbery. My grandfather lists this job as simply “remodel”. The numbering sequence between the house in 1916 and the remodel job would indicate that this job was probably sometime in 1928. The building that the bank was located in during the 1920’s still exists today. It has seen various uses over the years and is now in very poor condition. The interior of the bank no longer exists as it did in 1928 after remodeling.

  9. George Studdard says:

    My earliest years were spent in Strawn and Thurber. The robbery in Cisco had happened just over a year before I was born but was still a hot topic of conversation. After moving to Fort Worth in 1933 we met a neighbor two doors away from our house on Hurley Street. His name was Boyce House.

    • hometown says:

      George, despite all my years–like you–at the Star-Telegram, I had never heard of House until I started this blog. In fact, I think it was our ex-colleague Fred Blalock who suggested I research House.

  10. Derek Taylor says:

    Thank you for these articles. I’m always looking for more information on Fort Worth and her history. Well written and entertaining!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *